Write to find out what you think

Writing Guide >

The principle

Most people believe they think first and write second: work the argument out in your head, then write it down. For anything beyond the trivial, that is not how it works. You do not fully know what you think until you have written it. A sentence that will not come out straight is usually a sign that the thought behind it is not straight either. Writing is not the transcription of thinking. It is the method.

Why it fails in practice

Treating writing as transcription produces two failures.

The first is paralysis. The writer will not start until the thinking is 'done', and so waits at a blank page for a clarity that only writing could have produced. The thinking never finishes in the head, because the head is not where the hard part gets finished.

The second looks like success, which makes it worse. The writer more or less knows what they want to say, writes it down fluently, and never finds out that the argument has a hole in it. The fluency is the problem: it feels like competence, and it lets you skip the thinking that writing would have forced. A smooth draft of an untested case is not a thought-through document. It is a gap, written neatly.

An example

You sit down to write a paper recommending the option you already favour. You know the answer; this is just the writing-up. Then you reach the paragraph where the numbers are meant to settle it, and they do not. The saving is smaller than you remembered, or it rests on an assumption you cannot defend in a sentence. You did not know that until you tried to write the sentence, and the recommendation that comes out of the finished paper is not the one you sat down with.

That is not writing going wrong. That is writing doing its job. The alternative was not a better paper. It was the same weak case, written more confidently, and found out by the reader instead of by you.

What to do instead

Write early and write badly. Start before you feel ready, in whatever form lets you think: notes, a rough argument to yourself, full sentences you know you will throw away. This draft is not meant to produce text. It is meant to find out what you think, and to find the holes while they are still yours to fix.

Then set it aside. What you have found is the answer; the draft that found it is not the document you send. That is a separate act, and it starts from the answer you now hold, which is where 'Decide the answer before you start' begins.

← Back to the Writing Guide