Decide the answer before you start

Writing Guide >

The principle

Before you write the document that goes to the reader, settle what it concludes. Not the topic, not the question it addresses, but the answer: the recommendation, the position, the one thing you want the reader to take away. Write it down in a sentence. Everything in the document is then either support for that sentence or it does not belong.

This is the step after 'Write to find out what you think'. You wrote the first draft to discover the answer. Now you have it, and the document you send is built from it, rather than being a second search for the answer conducted in front of the reader.

Why it fails in practice

A document written without a settled answer wanders, because it is still looking for one. It works through the analysis in the order the writer happened to do it, weighs everything evenly because it has not decided what matters, and reaches a conclusion that reads like a surprise to its own author. The reader feels the drift even when they cannot name it.

Writers skip the step because deciding is harder than drafting, and committing to an answer in advance feels like closing off options too soon. So they keep their options open by writing a document that never quite commits, and call it balanced. It is not balanced. It is undecided, in public.

An example

A paper written from a decided answer and one written in search of it can cover identical ground and read completely differently. The first states its recommendation at the top and spends its length showing why. The second recounts the investigation, we looked at this, then at that, on the other hand there is this, and parks the recommendation at the end, tentatively, where the writer finally ran out of road. Same facts, same analysis. One was decided before it was written; the other was written in the hope of deciding.

What to do instead

When the discovery draft has done its work, write one sentence: 'This document asks the reader to [do X], because [Y].' If you cannot write it, you are not ready to write the document. You are still thinking, which means going back a step. If you can write it, that sentence is the spine. Put it near the top, as 'Put the answer at the top' sets out, and make everything else earn its place against it.

← Back to the Writing Guide